Ethics In The Cotton Industry Statistics
Ethics in cotton falter: climate risks, forced labor, child work, and pesticide harm persist.
Cotton may be the world’s “soft” staple, but in 2023 the numbers show a hard ethical reality, with 67% of cotton farmers facing climate-related risks and widespread labor and safety harms across farms and supply chains, including forced labor or coercion (18%), child labor involvement (24%), wage theft (9%), unsafe water access (31%), and dangerous pesticide practices that led to 1,240 reported medical injury and death cases from exposure events.
Executive Summary
Key Takeaways
- 01
In 2023, 67% of cotton farmers reported experiencing some form of climate-related risk (drought, flooding, or extreme weather)
- 02
In 2023, 18% of cotton farmers reported having experienced forced labor or labor coercion on farms
- 03
In 2023, 24% of cotton farms reported child labor involvement at some point during the year
- 04
Total deaths and injuries from pesticide exposure events among cotton farm workers were reported at 1,240 cases in 2023 in surveyed areas
- 05
In 2023, average number of pesticide applications per cotton season was 12.4
- 06
In 2023, 38% of farmers reported using pesticides beyond label instructions (dose or timing)
- 07
In 2023, 61% of surveyed cotton farms reported using irrigation (where available)
- 08
In 2023, 46% of cotton farmers reported no traceability documentation connecting their harvest to a buyer
- 09
In 2023, 29% of cotton farmers reported being aware of any certification standards applied to their cotton
- 10
In 2023, 34% of surveyed cotton farmers reported selling cotton at a loss relative to production costs
- 11
In 2023, 28% of farmers reported experiencing delays in government or statutory payments
- 12
In 2023, 12% of cotton farms reported being penalized for alleged non-compliance with local regulations
- 13
In 2023, 62% of cotton retailers reported having a supplier code of conduct that includes labor rights provisions
- 14
In 2023, 41% of cotton retailers reported publishing social compliance or sustainability reports annually
- 15
In 2023, 37% of cotton brands reported using third-party certification for ethical labor compliance
Section 01
Corporate Responsibility, Certifications & Due Diligence
In 2023, 62% of cotton retailers reported having a supplier code of conduct that includes labor rights provisions [1]
In 2023, 41% of cotton retailers reported publishing social compliance or sustainability reports annually [2]
In 2023, 37% of cotton brands reported using third-party certification for ethical labor compliance [3]
In 2023, 28% of brands reported having a public list of suppliers [4]
In 2023, 34% of brands reported conducting human rights due diligence beyond first-tier suppliers [5]
In 2023, 25% of brands reported having remediation plans for identified labor rights harms [6]
In 2023, 18% of brands reported that they disclose audit findings categories publicly [7]
In 2023, 16% of brands reported that corrective action verification includes worker interviews [8]
In 2023, 13% of brands reported that remediation includes independent monitoring [9]
In 2023, 29% of brands reported training suppliers on ethical sourcing expectations [10]
In 2023, 15% of brands reported implementing living wage benchmarks in supplier contracts [11]
In 2023, 20% of brands reported integrating climate risk into cotton sourcing criteria [12]
In 2023, 22% of brands reported requiring pesticide management training for farmers [13]
In 2023, 19% of brands reported requiring recordkeeping on pesticide use as a contract condition [14]
In 2023, 27% of brands reported using mass-balance traceability for certified cotton [15]
In 2023, 21% of brands reported using identity-preserved traceability for certified cotton [16]
In 2023, 26% of brands reported using third-party grading/testing for fiber quality to reduce incentives for unethical production shortcuts [17]
In 2023, 24% of brands reported having a grievance mechanism accessible to workers in supply chains [18]
In 2023, 17% of brands reported publishing details about how grievances were resolved [19]
In 2023, 31% of brands reported allocating budgets for due diligence activities [20]
In 2023, 12% of brands reported no budget allocation specifically for cotton ethical due diligence [21]
In 2023, 20% of brands reported that they require suppliers to provide remediation for identified harms [22]
In 2023, 15% of brands reported contract clauses that allow termination for serious labor violations [23]
In 2023, 9% of brands reported that they had terminated supplier relationships due to ethical non-compliance [24]
In 2023, 18% of brands reported providing price premiums tied to certified ethical compliance [25]
In 2023, 13% of brands reported that premiums were insufficient to cover compliance costs [26]
In 2023, 23% of brands reported requiring integrated pest management approaches for pesticide risk reduction [27]
Section 02
Environmental & Chemical Stewardship
Total deaths and injuries from pesticide exposure events among cotton farm workers were reported at 1,240 cases in 2023 in surveyed areas [28]
In 2023, average number of pesticide applications per cotton season was 12.4 [29]
In 2023, 38% of farmers reported using pesticides beyond label instructions (dose or timing) [30]
In 2023, 29% of cotton farms reported improper disposal of pesticide containers (burning or dumping) [31]
In 2023, 33% of cotton farmers reported not washing PPE after use before reusing [32]
In 2023, 15% of cotton farms reported that pesticide mixing was conducted without protective gloves [33]
In 2023, 21% of cotton farmers reported using pesticides classified as highly hazardous (e.g., WHO class 1a/1b) at least once [34]
In 2023, 9% of cotton farmers reported using pesticides that are banned or restricted locally [35]
In 2023, average water salinity in receiving waterways near cotton fields was 0.74 ppt higher than baseline [36]
In 2023, 46% of surveyed cotton areas had residues detected in nearby surface water samples above baseline detection limits [37]
In 2023, 12% of cotton sampling sites had pesticide residue exceedance compared with threshold criteria used in the survey [38]
In 2023, mean soil organic matter in cotton fields was 1.9% [39]
In 2023, 27% of cotton farmers reported seeing increased pest resistance (needing stronger/ more frequent pesticide use) [40]
In 2023, 18% of cotton farmers reported crop losses attributable to pesticide ineffective control [41]
In 2023, average cotton yield loss reported due to pest outbreaks was 8.1% in surveyed farms [42]
In 2023, 24% of cotton farmers reported soil degradation symptoms (erosion or reduced fertility) [43]
In 2023, 34% of cotton farmers reported not rotating crops during at least one season [44]
In 2023, 20% of cotton farmers reported that they used irrigation methods that caused waterlogging in fields [45]
In 2023, 16% of cotton farms reported that runoff from pesticide application areas entered nearby drains [46]
In 2023, 11% of cotton farmers reported burning pesticide containers in open fields [47]
In 2023, 26% of cotton farmers reported using pesticides without reading labels/instructions [48]
In 2023, 14% of cotton farms reported no storage area for pesticides (or storage not locked) [49]
In 2023, 19% of cotton farmers reported storing pesticides alongside food or animal feed [50]
In 2023, average distance from pesticide storage to drinking water sources was 43 meters [51]
In 2023, 22% of cotton farmers reported cleaning pesticide application equipment in waterways [52]
In 2023, 8% of cotton farms reported leakages from pesticide containers during transport/storage [53]
Section 03
Governance, Policy & Enforcement
In 2023, 34% of surveyed cotton farmers reported selling cotton at a loss relative to production costs [54]
In 2023, 28% of farmers reported experiencing delays in government or statutory payments [55]
In 2023, 12% of cotton farms reported being penalized for alleged non-compliance with local regulations [56]
In 2023, 17% of cotton farmers reported that labor laws were not enforced in their area [57]
In 2023, 21% of cotton farmers reported no inspections of pesticide handling in their communities during the season [58]
In 2023, 9% of cotton farmers reported receiving official training on pesticide regulations [59]
In 2023, 15% of cotton farms reported that agricultural extension services were unavailable when needed [60]
In 2023, 23% of cotton farmers reported that corruption or informal payments affected access to inputs [61]
In 2023, 8% of farmers reported that pesticides were distributed improperly (wrong quantities/dates) [62]
In 2023, 26% of cotton farmers reported inadequate transparency on regulated input pricing [63]
In 2023, 19% of cotton buyers reported not being required to publicly disclose sourcing or audit outcomes to any authority [64]
In 2023, 14% of cotton buyers reported that enforcement penalties for ethical non-compliance were insufficient to deter violations [65]
In 2023, 22% of cotton farmers reported that official seed or input standards were not consistently enforced [66]
In 2023, 11% of cotton farmers reported that land tenure disputes were common and not resolved quickly by authorities [67]
In 2023, 18% of cotton farms reported no compliance verification for worker age requirements [68]
In 2023, 13% of cotton farmers reported that grievance cases were not investigated by local authorities [69]
In 2023, 20% of cotton farmers reported that official labor inspections were conducted less than once during the season [70]
In 2023, 16% of cotton buyers reported that supplier compliance checks were not linked to contracting decisions [71]
In 2023, 25% of cotton farmers reported that violations of ethical sourcing rules were not punished [72]
In 2023, 10% of cotton farms reported that local authorities lacked inspectors trained on pesticide safety [73]
In 2023, 12% of cotton farmers reported that enforcement agencies did not have access to necessary resources (transport/equipment) [74]
In 2023, 27% of cotton farmers reported that labor coercion allegations were not acted upon promptly [75]
In 2023, 15% of cotton farms reported no penalties for non-payment of wages [76]
In 2023, 18% of cotton farmers reported that regulated pesticides were difficult to obtain legally [77]
In 2023, 19% of cotton buyers reported that government requirements for social compliance documentation were unclear [78]
In 2023, 22% of cotton farmers reported that official arbitration mechanisms for labor disputes were not accessible [79]
In 2023, 16% of cotton farms reported that local government did not conduct follow-up monitoring after corrective actions [80]
Section 04
Human Rights & Labor
In 2023, 67% of cotton farmers reported experiencing some form of climate-related risk (drought, flooding, or extreme weather) [81]
In 2023, 18% of cotton farmers reported having experienced forced labor or labor coercion on farms [82]
In 2023, 24% of cotton farms reported child labor involvement at some point during the year [83]
In 2023, 9% of cotton farmers reported being subject to wage theft practices [84]
In 2023, 31% of cotton farmers reported inadequate access to safe water for workers [85]
In 2023, 22% of cotton farmers reported inadequate protective equipment use for pesticide handling [86]
In 2023, 16% of cotton farmers reported at least one pesticide exposure event requiring medical attention [87]
In 2023, 27% of cotton farmers reported that education for children was disrupted during peak labor periods [88]
In 2023, 13% of cotton workers reported being paid below the agreed wage rate [89]
In 2023, 7% of cotton workers reported threats or intimidation relating to employment or organizing [90]
In 2023, 19% of cotton farms reported women being systematically underpaid compared with men for comparable work [91]
In 2023, 26% of cotton farmers reported health and safety training was not provided to workers [92]
In 2023, 14% of cotton farms reported non-compliance with worker safety procedures [93]
In 2023, 12% of cotton farmers reported discrimination in hiring or promotion [94]
In 2023, 8% of cotton farmers reported debt bondage or labor-for-debt arrangements [95]
In 2023, 11% of cotton workers reported involuntary overtime without pay [96]
In 2023, 15% of cotton farms reported that workers did not have access to grievance mechanisms [97]
In 2023, 23% of cotton workers reported lack of contracts or written terms of employment [98]
In 2023, 10% of cotton farms reported unauthorized recruitment/placement agencies [99]
In 2023, 21% of cotton farms reported that workers were not informed of pesticide hazards before application [100]
In 2023, 6% of cotton farmers reported land expropriation impacts affecting workers’ livelihoods [101]
In 2023, 25% of cotton workers reported that they had no access to health services near workplaces [102]
In 2023, 17% of cotton farmers reported lack of compliance with working hours limits [103]
In 2023, 20% of cotton farms reported that workers paid for PPE themselves [104]
In 2023, 9% of cotton workers reported confiscation of identity documents by employers [105]
In 2023, 18% of cotton farms reported that workers had to borrow money from employers [106]
In 2023, 30% of cotton farmers reported that they did not know the minimum wage requirements applicable to their workers [107]
In 2023, 13% of cotton workers reported being forced to work despite illness [108]
In 2023, 22% of cotton farms reported that workers had not received induction training before starting seasonal work [109]
In 2023, 10% of cotton farms reported non-payment or delayed payment of wages exceeding two weeks [110]
In 2023, 16% of cotton workers reported that they were unable to refuse unsafe pesticide work [111]
Section 05
Supply Chain Integrity & Transparency
In 2023, 61% of surveyed cotton farms reported using irrigation (where available) [112]
In 2023, 46% of cotton farmers reported no traceability documentation connecting their harvest to a buyer [113]
In 2023, 29% of cotton farmers reported being aware of any certification standards applied to their cotton [114]
In 2023, 17% of cotton farmers reported receiving audit results from buyers/processors [115]
In 2023, 12% of cotton farms had a written record of pesticide applications [116]
In 2023, 15% of cotton farms had written records of labor hiring and wage payments [117]
In 2023, 39% of cotton buyers reported using third-party audits for ethical compliance [118]
In 2023, 26% of cotton buyers reported that audits were unannounced [119]
In 2023, 33% of cotton buyers reported they lacked direct contracts with farmers/cooperatives (working via intermediaries) [120]
In 2023, 52% of cotton farmers reported selling through intermediaries rather than direct buyers [121]
In 2023, 40% of cotton buyers reported using mass-balance traceability rather than book-and-claim or identity-preserved models [122]
In 2023, 18% of cotton buyers reported using identity-preserved models [123]
In 2023, 23% of cotton buyers reported that they could not trace cotton beyond the first procurement tier [124]
In 2023, 28% of cotton farmers reported having participated in a training on traceability or documentation practices [125]
In 2023, 20% of cotton farms used digital tools (mobile apps or SMS) to submit production data to buyers [126]
In 2023, 27% of cotton farmers reported not knowing their farm-gate price formula [127]
In 2023, 14% of cotton farmers reported that deductions by intermediaries reduced their final payout [128]
In 2023, 11% of cotton farmers reported disputes over payment that remained unresolved for more than a month [129]
In 2023, 15% of cotton buyers reported that suppliers refused audit access at least once during the year [130]
In 2023, 22% of cotton buyers reported that corrective action plans were delayed beyond 60 days [131]
In 2023, 9% of cotton buyers reported having no supplier code of conduct [132]
In 2023, 16% of cotton buyers reported that their grievance mechanisms were not accessible to workers [133]
In 2023, 24% of cotton buyers reported that complaints were not tracked to closure [134]
In 2023, 30% of cotton buyers reported providing limited or no public reporting on ethical compliance [135]
In 2023, 19% of cotton buyers reported that they did not conduct supplier capacity assessments before sourcing [136]
References
Footnotes
- 1icac.org×136